Deggans, CNN, and Anti-Gay Activists

Count me in the camp of those who aren’t crazy about using the legacy of Martin Luther King Jr. to make points about LGBT rights.  Oh, I understand the comparison and it makes sense.  But there’s something uncomfortable about white, LGBT activists using the King holiday to make points about LGBT rights.

Which leads me to a column by Eric Deggans, the media critic for the St. Petersburg Times.  Deggans isn’t white and he isn’t gay.  Yet, he makes an impassioned argument that the memory of Dr. King is harmed when the media–especially CNN–invites anti-gay activists on their show because they can’t find any other balance or experts.

Back in Dr. King’s time, when debates over issues of civil rights were covered by the media, they also dutifully included those who favored segregation or denying black people the vote or banning interracial marriage. But eventually, the news media concluded that such views were prejudiced and stopped presenting them as equal arguments — reasoning that treating racists like equal participants in such debates only granted them a power they should not have.

So when will media take similar action with anti-gay activists?

It seems a simple question. Either there’s an open question about whether being gay is harmful or hurtful — and no reputable psychologist or mental health professional says there is — or there isn’t. And if the act of being gay isn’t harmful, then why are otherwise reputable news organizations giving voice to people whose only expertise is their continued resistance to the mainstream acceptance of homosexuals?

It isn’t the first time the Deggans has made the comparison between civil rights and gay rights and we need more voices like Deggans questioning who is an appropriate guest or “expert” to represent voices opposed to gay rights. He also suggests that the media will soon regret giving voice to anti-gay voices who are extreme and vitriolic.

Still, perhaps CNN — and other media outlets worldwide — could consider honoring Dr. King today by changing its policies. Because, as I think about the history of America’s civil rights struggles, I’m reminded of all the newspapers which had to apologize for how they gave into prejudice and racism while covering Dr. King’s work more than 40 years ago.

CNN could avoid a similar apology by acting now. Maybe, just once, we could learn from our worst history instead of repeating it.

3 Responses

  1. Why does the idea of gay, white people “using” the legacy of Dr. King bother you? Just out of curiosity (because I’m sick of race baiting–that’s not at all what this question is) is it the gay part, the white part, or both? As someone who is gay and neither white nor black, I often cite Dr. King as a source of inspiration because the message resonates in all downtrodden communities and in all men, regardless of the labels (such as race, sexual orientation, religion, etc.) we put on ourselves.

  2. Good question. I guess I want to respect the significance Dr. King has for the African American civil rights struggle and for African Americans generally and allow that legacy to be focused on the civil rights movement and era without it needing to be applied to every other struggle.

  3. You are selling Dr. King short. He was always specific about the fact that the American civil rights movement was not limited to securing rights for African Americans. He was anti-war, anti-poverty, etc. In short, he was in favor of human rights and social justice. Coretta Scott King was very specific about how Dr. King’s vision extended to equal rights for sexual minorities as well as racial minorities.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: