What is “Outing” in 2010?

After I posted the news that Judge Walker had been “outed” by the San Francisco Chronicle, I saw a tweet from Lawdork blogger Chris Geidner where he asked whether this was really an “outing” since everyone appeared to know that Walker was gay. I tweeted back: “I’m not even sure I know what the definition of “outing” is anymore.”

When most people think of “outing,” they are likely thinking of the kind of thing done by Michelangelo Signorile, Michael Petrelis, and Michael Rogers where the decision to “out” someone who isn’t openly gay is done for political purposes.  Those who are “outed” generally have an anti-gay record or are viewed as hostile to the gay community. That approach has even extended, more recently, to gay Catholic priests.

(UPDATED: Signorile tweets: “My position misunderstood here: Always re: pub figure whenever relevant, good guys or bad.”)

But Judge Walker doesn’t really fall into this category.  He appears to live an openly gay life, he doesn’t have an anti-gay record, and he doesn’t appear to go out of his way to suggest he’s not gay. So is reporting the fact that everyone knows he is gay really an “outing”?

The NLGJA stylebook defines “outing” as: “Publicly revealing the sexual orientation or gender identity of an individual who has chosen to keep that information private. Also a verb: The magazine outed the senator in a front-page story.”

There are many people in public life–athletes, politicians, newscasters, entertainers, pundits–who live inside a “glass closet” where they don’t actively pretend to be straight and may actually live openly gay lives.  They just aren’t openly gay lives to the public outside of their inner circle.

In some ways, those people are even more difficult to report on.  While there are ethical arguments not to “out” people when the goal is political, that line doesn’t exist for people who haven’t held a press conference to announce they are gay and don’t answer questions from reporters about being gay, yet live lives as LGBT people. But we are loathe to report that a television personality has a boyfriend or a singer/actress goes to lesbian bars with her girlfriend or that the progressive politician isn’t just a single woman who can’t find a man.

So why is it that we don’t report this information, outside of the gossip pages?  And what happens when the gossip page story becomes a bigger news story? While the fact that a judge overseeing a high profile trial involving same-sex marriage is allegedly gay is newsworthy, when is a glass closeted person’s orientation not newsworthy?

There is an argument that it’s not news, except when it is “news.” There’s no reason to mention a television personality has a boyfriend unless that somehow has a news angle or it occurs in a public situation.  If an actress/singer is appearing in a new movie, is the fact that she has a girlfriend “news”?  What if she always shows up to premiers and award shows alone?  What if she shows up with a man?

So let’s open it up for a conversation.  What is “Outing” in 2010?

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine


3 Responses

  1. My critics at the SF Weekly are taking the Chronicle gossip columnists to task for not mentioning gay blogosphere chatter about the Judge Vaughn Walker being a gay man:


  2. […] that he is gay and has been in a 10-year relationship with a man. The story brings an end to one of 2010′s most interesting media ethics stories relating to the judge who everyone assumed was gay–and the […]

  3. […] people as LGBT and when not to.  Cook, like Elena Kagan and Judge Vaughan Walker before him, raises the question of what is “outing” in 2011 and is there really a problem with saying someone is gay […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: